Family trusts can play an important role in the financial affairs of healthcare professionals, whether they’re used as part of an investment structure, a medical practice, asset protection arrangements or longer-term succession planning.
But proposed changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts could mean some doctors, dentists and practice owners need to rethink how those structures work in the future.
Under legislation currently before Parliament, a minimum 30% tax would apply to certain discretionary trust income from 1 July 2028. Importantly, the legislation has not yet been passed, so making structural changes now may be premature.
What is worth doing now is understanding your current position.
For healthcare professionals, that starts with a much bigger question than simply: “How do I minimise the tax?” It’s about understanding why your trust exists in the first place, what you want it to achieve over the long term, and whether its current structure will continue to support those goals.
Healthcare professionals can build increasingly complex financial structures as their careers progress.
You might have practice interests, investments, business premises and other assets sitting across different entities. Your priorities may also change significantly between entering private practice, growing a practice and eventually planning your exit or retirement. That means there won’t necessarily be one “best” response to the proposed trust rules.
There are three broad pathways for affected discretionary trusts:
Each comes with different trade-offs.
The right question is therefore less about which option produces the lowest tax today and more about which structure supports where you want to be tomorrow.
Before considering any change, go back to the purpose of your trust.
Is it primarily there for:
holding investments or other assets?
operating a business?
asset protection?
succession and estate planning?
flexibility around distributions?
a combination of these?
These considerations matter because changing a structure to solve one tax problem could mean compromising another benefit you value.
For a doctor building wealth outside their practice, those priorities could look very different to a practice owner thinking about bringing in another practitioner, creating employee equity or eventually selling.
Yes. A 30% minimum tax doesn't automatically mean every affected trust needs to be restructured.
Keeping the existing structure may remain attractive where flexibility over distributions, the ability to accommodate future beneficiaries, asset protection or succession planning are particularly important. The cost of restructuring also needs to be weighed against the additional tax that would otherwise arise.
That distinction could be particularly important for medical professionals who have established structures with longer-term family and wealth-planning objectives.
There is another consideration if a trust currently distributes income to a corporate beneficiary, commonly referred to as a bucket company. Under the proposal, companies would not be able to use the trust tax offset, potentially resulting in tax being paid at both the trust and company level on those distributions.
So even where you ultimately decide to keep your trust, how it is being used may need attention.
A company structure may warrant consideration where a trust operates a larger trading business that retains and reinvests profits, or where a business is preparing for external investment, employee equity or a future sale.
But restructuring isn't simply a matter of swapping one entity for another. You need to consider the assets held within the trust, contracts and licenses, carried-forward losses, existing capital gains and potential transfer costs. Stamp duty can also be particularly significant depending on the assets involved and the state or territory in which they are located.
For a healthcare practice, that's why the decision needs to be considered as part of the practice's broader commercial plans, not as an isolated tax decision.
The proposed rules contain another option known as the excluded election trust, or EET, election.
Broadly, this would allow an eligible trust to retain its structure and avoid the proposed 30% minimum tax, but the trade-off is significant: beneficiaries and their respective shares of trust income and capital would need to be nominated.
In other words, you may be able to retain the trust, but you give up much of the flexibility that makes a discretionary trust useful in the first place.
Asset protection may be affected too. One of the key reasons many medical professionals use a discretionary trust is asset protection. Because, currently, no beneficiary has a fixed entitlement to the trust’s income or capital, those assets can be more difficult for creditors, claimants or litigants to reach. For doctors exposed to professional and business risk, that can be a significant benefit.
As an EET election requires beneficiaries and their shares to be nominated, that discretionary protection may be weakened or lost, and those interests could potentially be exposed to a beneficiary’s creditors or to relationship or estate disputes. Because the election is permanent, it’s important to understand this trade-off before it is made.
What about a bucket company? If your trust currently distributes to a bucket company, the EET election needs careful thought. The nomination of beneficiaries and their respective shares would need to be considered against how profits are currently streamed to the company, and any change could affect the amount of income the company can receive and how it is taxed. Where a trust doesn’t make the election, the company still can’t use the trust tax offset, so tax may be paid at both the trust and company level. Either way, the role of the bucket company should be reviewed with your advisor.
The election would be made once in the 2028–29 income year and would be permanent, with limited circumstances allowing changes. The trust would also need to exist on 1 July 2028 to qualify.
That makes this much more than an annual tax-planning decision. It could have consequences for future family, succession and wealth-planning arrangements.
Rather than choosing between “Option A, B or C” today, we think there are three more useful conversations to start.
Think beyond the next tax return.
Are you planning to grow your practice? Bring in another owner? Sell? Reduce your clinical workload? Build an investment portfolio? Retire? Transfer wealth to the next generation?
Your future plans should help shape the structure you need.
Every pathway involves a trade-off.
Keeping your existing trust could mean accepting additional tax. Moving to a company can introduce restructuring costs and other consequences. Making an EET election could mean surrendering valuable flexibility.
The lowest headline tax rate won't necessarily deliver the best overall outcome.
This is perhaps the most important question.
A structure established years ago may have made perfect sense when you were starting private practice or building your investment portfolio. But your career, family, assets and ambitions may look very different today.
Changes to the trust tax rules provide another reason to revisit those arrangements and make sure they're still working towards the future you want.
Not necessarily. The legislation has been introduced to Parliament but has not yet been passed, so acting before the final rules are known could be premature. The proposed minimum 30% tax is intended to commence from 1 July 2028.
But waiting for the legislation to pass doesn't mean ignoring the issue altogether.
Now is an opportunity to understand your existing structures, clarify what they're designed to achieve and identify where the proposed changes could affect your longer-term strategy.
For medical professionals with practices, investments and family wealth spread across multiple structures, that review is particularly important.
Because ultimately, the question isn't simply “How will my trust be taxed?”
It's “Is my financial structure still taking me where I want to go?”
The financial structures of medical and dental professionals often evolve alongside their careers. What works when you're establishing yourself in private practice may not be what you need as you grow your wealth, expand a practice or begin planning for succession.
Our Specialist Medical and Dental team can help you review your existing arrangements, understand how the proposed trust changes may affect you and consider your options in the context of your broader financial and business goals.
If you have a discretionary trust, now is a good time to start the conversation.